Reviewed by Greg Kasavin, [8/10]. "Between all the minigames and the inspired addition of a younger creature for your own creature to look after, you'll find that Creature Isle is a great place to visit."

Reviewed by Craig Wessel, [83/100]. "Keeps the flavor of the original, while adding new gameplay changes that remove much of the original's micro-management."

Reviewed by Rob Watkins, [8.7/10]. "Fans of Black & White will rejoice now that finally there's an expansion for it."