Review by Tom Anderson. "Easy to learn and use, but challenging to master, this totally immersive experience will not only create interest in the historical situation it represents, but provide months - maybe even years - of exciting gameplay.

Review by Emil Pagliarulo and Pete Hines. "Red Baron II could have been so much more. As it stands, hardcore WWI enthusiasts or those looking solely for multiplayer dogfights may find enough to like in this title, but those gamers searching for enjoyable single-player action probably won't find it here."