GameSpot
Reviewed by: Erik Wolpaw, score 6.9/10. "It's a well-made but entirely prosaic map pack."
Gamespot.com
[6.9] By Erik Wolpaw "It's a solid but unremarkable addition to the aging tactical shooter."
GameSpy.com
Review by Tom Chick [68/100] "There's not enough here to justify the cost if you already have Rogue Spear."
IGN
[7/10] Reviewed by: Steve Butts, score "It may seem dated, but it's still hard to argue against even more Rogue Spear."
The Electric Playground
Reviewed by Jason MacIsaac [8/10] "...good way to leave things until we see what Red Storm has to show us next."
TotalVideogames.com
Reviewed by Stephen Leyton [7/10] "There really is nothing new to Black Thorn that will make you go 'wow'."