ActionTrip: MechCommander 2
Reviewed, [71/100]. "MechCommander 2 is, unfortunately a game with no soul."
Apollo Guide: Mech Commander
Reviewed by Gareth Dickson, [82/100]. "The game is a success, and worthwhile for anyone interested in the MechWarrior series or tactical combat games."
Armchair Empire: MechCommander 2
Reviewed by: Omni, [8.6/10]. "There's something very appealing about 60-ton mechanized warriors blowing things up and making money at the same time."
Game Revolution: Mech Commander 2
Reviewed by Johnny B., [B+]. "It does everything it has to and does it well, but it doesn't do anything new."
GamePro.com: Mech Commander 2
Reviewed by Jake The Snake, [4/5]. "Fans of giant robots and strategy games will enjoy stomping around in this one."
GameSpot: MechCommander
Reviewed by Greg Kasavin, [7.3/10]. "A solid effort right down to its glossy packaging and colorful documentation."
GameSpot: MechCommander 2
Reviewed by Bruce Geryk, [7.7/10]. "a significant improvement upon the original in numerous ways, particularly in the interface."
GameSpot: MechCommander Gold
Reviewed by Greg Kasavin, [7.5/10]. "Its limited scope will feel frustratingly familiar to MechCommander veterans, although newcomers should enjoy the game in its more refined state."
GameSpy.com: MechCommander 2
Reviewed by William Abner, [84/100]. "MechCommander 2 is a winner. If you have the horses to run it, it's worth every penny. "
Gamezilla: MechCommander 2
Reviewed by William Brandt, [Fans Only]. "I'm positive that anyone who has played any of the prior Mech games will really have some fun with this one."
GameZone.com: MechCommander 2
Reviewed by Immortal, [9.3/10]. "Microsoft got the formula right, and it shows."
IGN: MechCommander 2
Reviewed by Steve Butts, [8.2/10]. " The linear single player game still offers a bit more variety than usual."
The Adrenaline Vault: MechCommander
Reviewed by Chris Harding, [2/5]. "I'm happy to say I beat Mechcommander. I'm happier to say that I won't have to play it again anytime soon."
The Adrenaline Vault: MechCommander 2
Reviewed by Bob Mandel, [4/5]. "MechCommander 2 is a very good stab, much better than its predecessor, aimed at fulfilling this need."
The Adrenaline Vault: MechCommander Gold
Reviewed by Chris Harding, [3.5/5]. "While MechCommander Gold is dramatically better than its older brother, for all intents and purposes, it is merely the same game with some new missions and one huge patch."
The Electric Playground
Reviewed by Scott Steinberg, [7.5/10]. "Layers of depth and beauty characterize an honestly memorable and fun virtual war zone."
The Gamers Temple: MechCommander 2
Review, [85%]. "An excellent and enjoyable tactical combat game for those who don't enjoy base building or resource gathering."