Review by Daniel Castellanos, A. "The graphics are great, the sound is great, the missions are great, multiplay is great; the only real drawback is the lack of story in solo play."

Review by Calvin Hubble, A-. "Although sounds and graphics are not the best around, the combination of realistic controls and addictive game-play could keep any gamer playing for hours on end."

Review by James Anthony. "While X-Wing vs TIE Fighter is sensational for solo play, its designers have developed it for use as a multi-player game that, by all accounts, is out of this world."

Review by Richard Law, 78%. "X-Wing vs. TIE Fighter is a decent game that should have been great."

Review by Michael P. Calligaro. "There's nothing here, absolutely nothing."

Review by Jim Brumbaugh, 4.5/5. "Although some of the missions seem reminiscent of those in previous incarnations, the upgraded graphics engine and attention to detail will provide die-hard fans of the previous titles with the definition they may have felt was lacking in the predecessors."

Review by Rog, 8/10. "Here is where the most glaring problem with XvT is evident: Giving people what they asked for doesn't necessarily make a great game."