Armchair Empire
Reviewed by Omni, score: 7.8/10. "As a Trek game Star Trek Armada II is above average, but as a RTS game it's simply standard."
Game Zone
Reviewed by: Rgerbino, score 8/10. "The big bad Borg strikes back again."
GameSpot
Reviewed by: Greg Kasavin, score 7.1/10. "A good real-time strategy game by any other standards."
GameSpot
Previewed by: Scott Osborne. "Building on one of the most popular Trek games to date by trying to recapture Armada's core RTS gameplay dynamic."
GameSpy
Reviewed by: Tim McConnaughy, score 80%. "Just like the movie sequels, the even-numbered ones are the best."
Gamezilla
Reviewed by: Jim Weber, score 83%. "Has a number of new features and additions to gameplay that create a new experience."
Gaming Age
Reviewed by: Ryan Thompson, score C-. "Ultimately it is the lack of polish found pretty much everywhere in the game that makes it feel like less of a sequel and more like a pricey Star Trek: Armada MOD."
IGN
Previewed by: Mike Morrissey. "Play as several different races in more than 90 different ships, is it a good Star Trek game?"
IGN
Reviewed by: Ivan Sulic, score 7.4/10. "It does all the things a sequel should, but does it do them right, and more importantly, is it Trek?"
The Electric Playground
Reviewed by: Jason MacIsaac, score 77%. "Activision and Mad Doc clearly tried to expand the scope of the gameplay."