1UP
Review, by Sam Kennedy: "On a whole, Sega Classics Collection does deliver quite a bit of gameplay for your buck (especially considering it comes in at a budget price)." [Score: 5 out of 10]
GameSpot
Review, by Jeff Gerstmann: "With their pathetically outdated 3D performance, poor sound, and compromised gameplay, Sega Classics Collection is nearly impossible to enjoy." [Score: 3.2 out of 10]
GameSpy PS2
Review, by David Chapman: "10 games for twenty bucks is a pretty good deal, even if you only find a few to genuinely enjoy." [Score: 3 out of 5]
IGN PS2
Review, by Craig Harris: "Only a couple of these titles are the real deal; the rest really aren't worthy enough to carry the classics' moniker because, for the most part, the teams responsible for the recreations clearly didn't understand what made the original games great to begin with." [Score: 5.3 out of 10]