Stephen Thomas Erlewine's review: "The record isn't weaker than its predecessor because it repeats the formula of Boy, it's because the band tries too hard to move forward." 3 out of 5 stars.

Mark Prindle's review: "In short, not a bad album at all. But not up to the standards of early U2, if you ask me." Rating: 7/10.

Jon Pareles' review: "U2 are obviously attempting to vary their sound, but none of the strategies works as well yet as their basic power-trio dynamics." 3 out of 5 stars.