Chris Houlihan's review: "The diehards will hate this album; everyone else can feel free to dive in."

Jim Steed's review: "The songs on Here's to Shutting Up are strong, however, ultimately, this collection of songs is forgettable when compared to Superchunk's best works." Rated 9 out of 12.

Ryan Schreiber's review: "Of course, at the end of the day, Here's to Shutting Up isn't anything spectacular." Rated 7.9.

Karthik's review: "a record that sounds like a combination between the Jim O'Rourke produced "Come Pick Me Up", 1994's "Foolish", and 1995's "Here's Where the Strings Come In"."