Laura Sinagra's review: "...the Daisy razor's edge and cunning lingo that changed the lives of upper-middle-class white twenty-something indie-rockers are still in effect."

R. Brookman's review: "A distillation of Guyville's rangy, DIY songcraft and Whip-Smart's pop pretensions, Whitechocolatespaceegg reveals Phair for the rock star she should - but probably won't - be." Rating of 9.

Bill Aicher's review: "more mature than her earlier works, but not too much that she has lost the Phair flair."

Piero Scaruffi's review: "ranks as an impressive re-invention of Phair as folk-rock all-star."

Cynthia Joyce's review: "What ultimately makes 'Whitechocolatespaceegg' compelling is not clever song craft or cunning lyrics, but the very adultlike air of acceptance that pervades the album."