Ned Raggett's review: "Performances throughout are at the least fine and at the most fantastic." 4.5 stars.

CMJ review: "Starfish is a highly lyrical and textured work, with acoustic and electric guitars ringing, chiming and swirling to stunning effect-the band's trademark-now more refined and vibrant than before."

David Fricke's review: "Starfish is an album that will disorient and fascinate; shaking its spell will not be easy." 4 stars.