AMG All Music Guide: Gold Afternoon Fix
Ned Raggett's review: "things move between hit and miss, but there's enough character coming through to ensure a pleasant listen." 3 stars.
CMJ: Gold Afternoon Fix
CMJ review: "Their uncanny ability to create a subtle hook (especially on the lead single "Metropolis") gives The Church all the more power."
Rolling Stone: Gold Afternoon Fix
Chris Mundy's review: "The album, at its strongest, captivates with the understated elegance of its intricate guitars and soothing harmonies." 4 stars.