english deutsch
24 Frames Per Second
"One whopping bore of a movie." With an opposing reaction.
About.com
DVD review by Ivana Redwine [4/5].
Ain't It Cool News
Advice on how to watch the movie.
All-Reviews.com
A small collection of reviews. [Overall: 3/4]
Apollo Leisure Guide
Review of the huge, but disappointing, blockbuster [79/100], with user ratings.
BBC News
A collection of British news and reviews.
Boxoffice Magazine
"Eye candy isn't a reward in and of itself - it has to be backed by substance." [2/4]
Brunching Shuttlecocks
Review by the Self-Made Critic.
Canoe
"Stellar good fun."
Chicago Reader
Just worth seeing. [2/4]
CNN
"Visually dazzling 'Phantom Menace' lacks heart, soul."
Culturekiosque Nouveau
"Beyond its mundane awfulness, this film is actually pernicious." Lengthy intellectual slamming of the film.
Culturevulture.net
'Visually the film is a feast, a gourmet banquet. All other parts are peanut butter and jelly on 22-year-old white bread.'
Dark Horizons
Review links and news archives.
Darkside Review
An editorial reaction to critics.
Dr. Daniel's Movie Emergency
A folksy and positive review.
E! Online
"Starts well, goes to hell." [Grade: C]
EastWesterly
Analysis of the movie's parallels with Christianity.
Entertainment Weekly
Critical review and mediocre evaluation.
Epinions.com
Consumer reviews.
Haro Online
Review which rates movie as Not Bad covers special effects, plot, relationship to the original movies and cast.
Hollywood Jesus - The Phantom Menace (1999)
Visual movie review explains Biblical and spiritual themes in the film. Reviewer explains Darth Maul as symbolic of Satan being thrown in the bottomless pit.
Infilm Australia
Three different evaluations.
Kids in Mind
Parents' review charting questionable content in the movie.
Light Views
"An emotionally distant star." [Worth: $5]
Metromix
Positive review. [3.5/4]
Movie Magazine International
"The Phantom Menace is a solid action thriller with spectacular visual effects and a promising story line."
Movie Review Query Engine
A directory of links to many online reviews.
MovieJuice!
Positive and satirical review.
Movies for Guys
Capsule review of the DVD edition [3/5].
MovieThing
A selection of fan commentaries.
NPR: Morning Edition - The Phantom Menace
Streaming audio from the morning the movie was reviewed. Requires the Real Player.
Orlando Weekly
"After a 16-year gap in its ongoing saga (and a 22-year directorial hiatus for creator George Lucas), the "Star Wars" series is back with all of its virtues intact." [4.5/5]
ReelViews
"Still among the best 'bang for a buck' fun that can be had in a movie theater." [3.5/4]
Roger Ebert
Positive review of the effects and story. [3.5/4]
Rotten Tomatoes
Several reviews and reactions from critics. Includes some general movie information.
Salon: What's Wrong (And Right) With "T
Science fiction author David Brin scours the film for signs of intelligent life.
Salt Lake City Deseret News
"Just judge it on its own merits and leave all your preconceptions at the door." [3/4]
San Francisco Chronicle
News report on the charity benefit preview.
Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Positive editorial on the movie's philosophy.
Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Question and answers give the movie and thumbs up. [Grade: B+]
Seattle Times
Criticism that the movie fails to live up to the hype.
Subjective Camera
Favorable plot analysis. [3.5/4]
Teen Movie Critic
Trashes the movie. [1/4]
The Common Guy
"I liked The Phantom Menace." [Grade: B+]
The Disgusting World of Film Criticism: The Phanto
Review by Mr. Pop Culture.
The DVD Journal
"Those of you waiting in line are ... setting yourselves up for a grave disappointment." [2/4]
The Flick Filosopher
Fairly positive plot evaluation.
The New Special Effects
Personal rant about the special effects.
The Phantom Menace: A Response to Critics
An analysis of the criticisms of the movie, from wooden characters to supposed racial stereotypes, and a defense of the movie.
The Projectionist
Argues that the movies live up to the hype. [4.5/5]
The Sci-Fi Movie Page
DVD Review. [Movie: 2/4; Disc: 4/4]
The Tech
"The force still seems to be with George Lucas."
TheForce.Net Editorials
A small collection of fan reviews.
USA Today
Plot overview and review. [3/4]
World Magazine
A Christian perspective in three reviews: "Phantom Characters"; "Battling the Cultural Menace"; and "Faith vs. The Force".